GuideHQ

How do I cook a recipe when I do not have the equipment it asks for?

Which pieces of kitchen equipment can be substituted with something you already own, which cannot, and how to judge the difference safely.

Difficulty
beginner
Time
10 min
Read
4 min
Safety
caution

Short answer

Substitute freely on shape and volume: a roasting tin for a casserole dish, a colander over a pan for a steamer, a wine bottle for a rolling pin, a bag with a corner cut off for a piping bag. Do not substitute on heat resistance or pressure — nothing goes in an oven unless it is ovenproof, and nothing improvised holds pressure.

Most recipe equipment lists are aspirational. A few items genuinely do something nothing else does; a great many are a particular size and shape of metal that you already own in another form. The trick is telling those two categories apart before you find out the hard way.

Safety

Improvising is fine for shape and size and not fine for heat and pressure. Never put a plastic bowl, a sealed jar, an unmarked glass dish or a pan with a plastic handle into a hot oven, and never improvise anything that holds pressure. Glass and ceramic that are not marked ovenproof can shatter without warning.

Step by step

  1. Ask what the item does, not what it is called.A ramekin is a small ovenproof dish. A springform tin is a tin whose sides come away so you do not have to turn a fragile cake out. A mandoline makes very thin, very even slices. Once you have the function you can see whether you own something that performs it.
  2. Substitute tins and dishes on volume, and adjust the timing.Any ovenproof dish of about the right capacity will work. Fill it to a similar depth to the original — depth drives cooking time far more than shape does. Shallower means faster and more browned; deeper means slower and wetter. Check well before the stated time if you have gone shallower.
  3. Improvise the common tools confidently.Rolling pin: a wine bottle. Piping bag: a food bag with a corner cut off. Steamer: a metal colander or sieve over a pan of simmering water with a lid, or a heatproof plate on three balls of foil. Cooling rack: the grill pan rack. Pastry cutter: a glass. Sieve for straining stock: a clean tea towel in a colander. Mortar: the end of a rolling pin in a sturdy bowl.
  4. Improvise a lid, a rack and a bain-marie.A lid can be a baking tray, a larger plate or a doubled sheet of foil crimped round the rim. A roasting rack can be a bed of thickly sliced onion and carrot, which also flavours the juices. An oven bain-marie is any deep tray with hot water in it.
  5. Know the small list of things with no real substitute.A pressure cooker cannot be improvised. A thermometer cannot be replaced by judgement for anything where safety depends on the number. A food processor's blade work — pastry, nut butters, fine emulsions — is only approximated by hand and by a lot of time. A stand mixer's long whisking of meringue and enriched dough can be done by hand but genuinely is hard work.
  6. Check heat resistance before anything goes near an oven.Look for an ovenproof mark on glass and ceramic. Assume unmarked glass is not. Plastic handles, silicone spatulas and non-stick coatings all have maximum temperatures — usually printed on the item or its packaging. A pan handle that is fine on the hob may not be fine at 220°C.
  7. Accept a different result rather than forcing the method.Sometimes the honest answer is to change the recipe. No cake tin means make a traybake. No blender means a chunkier soup. No barbecue means a very hot griddle pan and a smoked ingredient for the flavour. That is a better outcome than an unsafe improvisation.

Tips

  • Two identical tins are worth more than one of each size. Most swaps come down to having something the right volume, and most kitchens are short on that rather than short on gadgets.
  • Line an improvised tin with baking paper whenever the shape is not what the recipe assumed. It compensates for corners, seams and unknown non-stick behaviour.
  • Weighing water is the quickest way to compare two dishes: 1ml of water weighs 1g, so fill the recipe's stated size on paper and fill yours, and you will know immediately whether it fits.

Common mistakes

  • Putting a non-ovenproof glass dish into a hot oven — Ordinary glass and even some tempered glass fails from thermal shock and can break violently, sending fragments through the food and the oven. Only use glassware marked as ovenproof.
  • Sealing a jar or a container to cook in it — Steam has to escape. A sealed vessel heated in an oven, a microwave or a pan of water builds pressure and can burst.

Questions people ask

Can I use a casserole dish instead of a Dutch oven?

Yes, if it is heavy, has a well-fitting lid and is safe on both hob and oven. If it is oven-only ceramic, brown the meat in a frying pan first and transfer.

What can I use instead of a steamer?

A metal colander or sieve set over a pan of simmering water with a lid on top, keeping the base clear of the water. A heatproof plate resting on three scrunched balls of foil in a lidded pan works for one portion.

Can I make bread without a stand mixer?

Yes, and most bread in the world is made by hand. Enriched, very wet doughs are the hardest by hand; a longer rest between short kneads does most of the work for you.

Written and maintained by the GuideHQ editorial team. More in Food & Cooking.